A scathing rebuttal to Strategy & Tactics magazines review of the AD&D Player's Handbook. Includes such vitriol as "What is worthy of comment, however, is the source of the critical commentary on AD&D being nothing more than a rewrite of D&D. Coming from an officer of SPI, the past masters of the rehash, artisans of the warmed-over WWII battle game, purveyors of the umpteenth version of the same, tired scenario, it is indeed a wonder that Mr. Berg would bring up such a spectre! In my view, however, this is not a case of the pot calling the kettle black, but rather a case of the pot complaining because its besooted vision causes it to imagine it detects a spot of tarnish on the silver salver above it."